Zythos Business
News

Self-Employed or Limited Company? When Incorporating Really Pays Off

Zythos Business

It is one of the questions we get asked most: “I’ve been self-employed for years, should I set up a limited company (SL)?” The honest answer is that it depends, and it almost never depends on turnover alone. In this guide we compare the real tax treatment of both options, the costs nobody mentions, and why the famous “above €40,000 it already pays off” figure is, at best, a very rough guideline.

Personal Income Tax vs. Corporate Tax: The Real Comparison

A self-employed person pays personal income tax (IRPF): all of the profit from the activity is added to their taxable base and taxed on a progressive scale. The more you earn, the higher the marginal rate, and that rate rises sharply in the upper brackets. Moreover, the profit is theirs whether they spend it or not: they are taxed on what they earn, not on what they withdraw.

A limited company pays Corporate Income Tax (IS), at a fixed general rate (25% under the general regime) and reduced rates for micro-enterprises and newly created entities under the conditions set by current legislation. The profit stays in the company and, as long as you don’t distribute it, you have only paid IS.

Here lies the trap of simplistic reasoning: that money is not yours yet. To access it you have two routes:

  • Draw a salary as a director or employee: it is a deductible expense for the company, but it is taxed in your personal income tax and generates Social Security contributions.
  • Pay out dividends: they have already been taxed under IS and are taxed again in your personal income tax as savings income.

An example with round, fictitious numbers: a company earns €60,000 before tax and pays IS at 25%, that is, €15,000. That leaves €45,000. If you distribute all of it as dividends, you will then pay personal savings income tax on it. The total combined burden can end up similar to that of a self-employed person, or even higher. The real advantage appears when you don’t need that money to live on and can leave it in the company to reinvest, deferring the second layer of taxation.

The Hidden Costs of a Limited Company

Comparing tax rates ignores what it costs to maintain the structure. These are the expenses that tend to be forgotten:

  • Incorporation: notary, Commercial Registry, administrative processing and, where applicable, share capital. It is an initial outlay, not a recurring cost, but it counts.
  • Mandatory and more complex accounting: the company must keep books in accordance with the Commercial Code and prepare annual accounts. It is a more expensive professional service than that of a self-employed person under the simplified direct assessment method.
  • Annual obligations: Corporate Income Tax, approval of accounts and filing with the Commercial Registry, minutes book and other formal requirements. Delays are penalised.
  • Director’s Social Security: if the shareholder-director has effective control, they normally must contribute as a self-employed company partner, paying the corresponding contribution, in addition to what the company already pays on their salary.
  • Rigidity: taking money out of the company without justification (shareholder loans, personal expenses) creates tax problems. Separation of assets is an advantage and also a discipline.

It is worth mentioning the positive side: limited liability protects your personal assets in many situations, although in practice banks and landlords often demand personal guarantees from small companies, so that protection is diluted more than it seems.

The Myth of “At €40,000 It Already Pays Off”

There is no magic figure. That amount gets repeated because, in certain cases, the IS saving compared with the marginal personal income tax rates starts to exceed the extra cost of the structure. But it leaves out decisive variables:

  • Turnover is not profit. What matters is the net result after expenses, not what you invoice.
  • How much you need to withdraw. If you live off everything you earn, the benefit of deferral disappears.
  • Your personal situation: other income, family allowances, regional deductions.
  • The type of activity: with heavy investment and reinvestment an SL fits better; in professional services with few expenses, the profit that can be retained tends to be smaller.
  • Withholdings and clients: some clients prefer to contract with companies, others with self-employed people, depending on the case.

A more useful criterion than a threshold: consider an SL when you have a stable, comfortable profit, don’t need to withdraw all of it, and want to reinvest, hire staff, bring in partners or limit risk. And before deciding, run a simulation with your real figures for at least the two scenarios (salary plus dividends, and self-employed), including Social Security contributions and administration costs.

Nor is it an irreversible decision, but undoing it has a cost: dissolving the company or transferring the business can trigger taxation, so it is best to plan for it from the start.

At Zythos Business we run that simulation with your numbers before you take the step: we compare total burdens, estimate the company’s costs, and tell you plainly whether it pays off today, whether it is better to wait, or whether staying self-employed is the most sensible option. And if you have already made the leap, we take care of the accounting, taxes and filing of annual accounts so that the company is an advantage and not a burden.

Discussion

There are 0 comments.